I wanted to see these two tarps in person.
So . . . I bought both.
And even though my hammock is MIA until next week . . . I wanted to set the two tarps up and take pictures for comparison purposes.
Here we go:
The stuff sacks:
The Speer bag (on the right) is actually fatter, but the tarp is packed more loosely in the bag (compared to the JRB).
Regular pitch:
1st, the JRB.
2nd, the Speer Winter Tarp:
Pull-outs and stitching:
1st, the JRB
and underside
ridgeline:
2nd, the Speer Winter Tarp
and the underside
underside of ridgeline:
Winter/storm pitch:
1st, the JRB:
(not the best setup by me, sides aren't properly set)
2nd, the Speer Winter Tarp:
(got distracted by dogs . . . didn't get another angle)
"Patio" pitch:
1st, the JRB:
2nd, the Speer Winter Tarp:
with flaps/doors tied up
Now I understand that my setup leaves something to be desired. I'm not really familiar with how to get the best pitch on each tarp yet.
My observations:
I feel that the stitching and finish on the JRB tarp is superior to the Speer Winter Tarp. It just looks and feels more "refined" in some ways. Having said that, I don't think that either tarp would have a seam or stitch failure. And from what I can tell . . . if they did, I think either manufacturer would take care of you.
I think that the pitch options on the Speer are superior to the JRB. I just like that the Speer pitches along one ridgeline with the ability to stretch, tie up, or close the door flaps. The JRB must be switched to its short ridgeline in order to use the flaps. It's hard to say without my hammock under it, but . . . my gut feeling is that I would find the storm (tarp-tent) pitch too short for my hammock.
As far as colors go . . . I think the JRB wins. I like the green or brown colors that the tarp is available in. Much better for stealth camping.
The Speer color is cheerier, I must admit. But I think you can spot that grey pretty easily in the woods. Good for some folks, not so good for stealth.
Which tarp will I keep? I'm torn. I'm leaning towards the Speer, because I prefer the pitch options. But the JRB is a well-made tarp in a pleasing color. Hmmmm.
Hope my pictures help some of the rest of you.
Bookmarks