Yes, how does anyone know for sure about any of the fabrics for a particular purpose unless performance has been verified?
I say that because there are several fabrics touted here and elsewhere which in some incarnation did not prove to perform as the seller and buyer expected. This has resulted in appropriate caution from some retailers. For example, the supplier verifies that the fabric is "down proof" for 850fp down, but there is no guarantee for lesser down. The RainShed, another outdoor fabric supplier, cautions that down proofness is no proof that the same fabric will not permit the fibers of this or that preferred synthetic fill to poke through.
WARNING: It CAN NOT be assumed that fabrics identified as “down proof by construction” will be satisfactory for use with PrimaLoft® insulation. Albany International Corp. disclaims any responsibility for fiber migration problems, including any that are not identified using the above testing guidelines. All customers should test all proposed fabric and insulation combinations using these or other methods in order to determine suitability.
And they go on to give recommendations for screening and testing for Primaloft(tm) as an example.
In the manufacturing world, testing for the particular application is part of 'gearing up', finding out what the limitations of the fabric are before adding value to it at some cost. A guarantee from the supplier is or should be worth something.
Then, there are performances that are a little soft. I read and can see that fussy people would complain about the Pertex used by Western Mountaineering (WM). I pull back through a few tufts (of millions?) each time I use one their SBs. I read in forums complaints about that as though WM were selling spreads made with equipment unwashed since it ground peanuts and tree nuts. I'm not so fussy, blessed to be without down alergies.
All that said, there are clues. The fabric is Pertex. If it is calendered --with a post-weaving shiny finish on one side -- then that finish is associated with down proofness. Then again, calendering seems to be associated, too, with wind-proofness.
Bookmarks