My thoughts as well. In the thread there was no mention that it was an HG Phoenix, just that the size and fit were the same. The PM doesn't jive with the thread and seems to indicate it is an HGP, but at the same time makes me wonder if he meant to say it was a Phoenix clone but had a brainfart and didn't communicate that correctly. "Custom" can mean both special-order or DIY, so again kinda iffy. I also find it tough to believe that a donating member with a solid amount of community participation would try to pass off a DIY job as an HG job, something that would be immediately apparent as soon as the purchaser failed to find any HG tags on it.
At any rate, I think the seller was ambiguous enough that he should honour a refund, honest mistake or not.
Bookmarks