PDA

View Full Version : Katadyn BeFree System



alifeoutdoors
03-25-2018, 16:08
Used this system last season and just wasn't happy with it. It started off strong but I don't think it likes the areas I backpack in. Discussion amongts others suggested the high tannins in our water here in the north woods was contributing to slow down. Or maybe it's just too many beaver bogs. In any case I'm just going to stay with my tried and true Sawyer Squeeze system. So I thought I'd offer it up free here to anyone that wanted to give it a shot. The filter in the original Katadyn bladder is the first I used and was running slow despite my efforts to shake / swish it clean. The backup filter that is not attached I only used on one three day trip into the Sylvania Wilderness. It was still flowing strong. The larger bladder is the Hydrapak 2L Seeker. I can ship from work so I'll send to anyone in the lower U.S. 48. If you're outside that area feel free to say I'll take it but you'll have to toss me a few bucks for shipping.

Thanks and may the snow melt be with you......

http://alifeoutdoors.com/images/beFree.JPG

Countrybois
03-25-2018, 17:09
Used this system last season and just wasn't happy with it. It started off strong but I don't think it likes the areas I backpack in. Discussion amongts others suggested the high tannins in our water here in the north woods was contributing to slow down. Or maybe it's just too many beaver bogs. In any case I'm just going to stay with my tried and true Sawyer Squeeze system. So I thought I'd offer it up free here to anyone that wanted to give it a shot. The filter in the original Katadyn bladder is the first I used and was running slow despite my efforts to shake / swish it clean. The backup filter that is not attached I only used on one three day trip into the Sylvania Wilderness. It was still flowing strong. The larger bladder is the Hydrapak 2L Seeker. I can ship from work so I'll send to anyone in the lower U.S. 48. If you're outside that area feel free to say I'll take it but you'll have to toss me a few bucks for shipping.

Thanks and may the snow melt be with you......

http://alifeoutdoors.com/images/beFree.JPG

I've heard good things... I'll give it a try. I'll take it.

alifeoutdoors
03-25-2018, 17:19
Right on, I'll PM you

hangnout
03-25-2018, 17:47
Used this system last season and just wasn't happy with it. It started off strong but I don't think it likes the areas I backpack in. Discussion amongts others suggested the high tannins in our water here in the north woods was contributing to slow down. Or maybe it's just too many beaver bogs. ......

Hmmm.............. Took both of mine to BWCA and they haven't worked right since. I also went back to Sawyer squeeze

Bobo1234
03-25-2018, 21:13
If for whatever reason it doesn't work out, I'd love to give it a try. Thanks for offering it up regardless!

Brewmaker
03-26-2018, 19:35
I spent a few days last week researching between the Saywer and and the Katadyn and was nervous about the some of the reported failures with the Katadyn. Lots of "success" stories with fast flow rates initially, but lots of slow downs reported, and a few cases of zero-flow. I read one post where someone was bought both (the Sawyer as the backup) and I thought that I'd rather deal with the slightly slower flow rates with the Sawyer to have the piece of mind that it will work rather than taking a small chance of being SOL on safe drinking water....

QFT
03-26-2018, 23:39
I found that both my BeFree and my Squeeze slowed down to just about no flow after I let it dry out for 2+ months. The squeeze never came back to normal but the BeFree did. I kind of wonder if some of the reports are due to an issue like that.

To fix the BeFree I soaked it in hot water for a few hours then pushed a bunch of it through.

alifeoutdoors
03-27-2018, 07:59
I found that both my BeFree and my Squeeze slowed down to just about no flow after I let it dry out for 2+ months. The squeeze never came back to normal but the BeFree did. I kind of wonder if some of the reports are due to an issue like that.

To fix the BeFree I soaked it in hot water for a few hours then pushed a bunch of it through.

I've heard that as well but I do a lot of backpacking over the season which is when it slowed down. So it was dry for no more than two weeks at most and I would always run a liter of tap water (good well water) through it before I headed out.

OneClick
03-27-2018, 08:02
That's nice of you to hand it off. I just got a new one but I have very little hope my experience will change this time around. I love it when it works, but water filtration is something you don't want to gamble with so I'll probably just go back to my gravity filter. I'll take this along as well to test since it's small and light enough.

alifeoutdoors
03-27-2018, 08:19
That's nice of you to hand it off. I just got a new one but I have very little hope my experience will change this time around. I love it when it works, but water filtration is something you don't want to gamble with so I'll probably just go back to my gravity filter. I'll take this along as well to test since it's small and light enough.

Aye, light and at least it's only $25 for a stand alone filter so that's why I just picked up a second towards the end of the season so I could give it a shot and have two to compare and contrast. Same for me, since I had my sawyer already set up in gravity mode might was well suck up the slightly slower but consistent flow rate and enjoy the scenery while it fills. At least its hands free so I can enjoy a snack while I relax.

dkurfiss
03-27-2018, 08:51
Hey guys, if you want to have a conversation about water filters please move over the Donating member section to do that. Since this item has been given a new home, I am going to close this thread.

Thanks