I will counter that a smaller tarp, no doors and a uqp will give a better view of the woods and for me that is a reason I choose the tarp life. The view I get from my hang and pitch is what it is all about to me and protection from elements can still be tweaked. I'll factor a uqp in on some trips like Linville Gorge when I know I want to awaken an see the morning glory. As I lay and have breakfast from the hammock and gaze out over the Gorge and feel it's damp breath wash over me my happiness level rings loud and true.
I've never been wet in my smaller DIY Blackcrow tarp. True the uqp boosts warmth a bit but I normally use it for a wind block and can be a little less concerned about my tarp pitch and height. Handy after a long day of toting a pack when I set up quickly and gulp some chow. Rarely do I use mine to boosts my insulation...though that is an option.
Of course some of this is trip and weather dependant. All a matter of choices and styles. Nothing is set in stone and I like that no absolutes apply.
But sometimes I bring a larger and lighter tarp with doors and have just as much fun.
Shug
Bookmarks