A difference of about 10oz max for the finished tarp sounds much but would be no significant weight penalty for me (as a biker no hiker) if I would get (hopefully!) a more than 2-fold better waterproof performance, a better durability, a better stability for severe weather conditions, most likely an easier and better sewing result and finally a nicer appearance of the finished DIY tarp.
I have a much heavier winter tarp (ripstop polyester with a undefined heavy coating ~4.2oz/sqyrd). This was one of the easiest fabrics I ever have sewn and you can see no single fold if I pitch this tarp. I can pitch it much stronger than my new silnylon tarp. Even the weight of this fabric is no big problem for me. The only problem I see is the fact that the coating is too stiff. This creates problems when I pack/unpack this tarp. A light silnylon or silpoly tarp in snakeskins is much easier to handle.
Btw: ExTex sells a lighter 1.27oz/sqyrd silnylon with 2000mm HH too.
http://www.extremtextil.de/catalog/R...ml?language=en
This fabric would already too light and also too expensive for me. I had even thoughts whether this fabric would be strong enough to withstand some severe weather conditions.
The problem is silnylon in general. I prefer silpoly too and would buy and most likely prefer it if it would be 1.94oz/sqyrd instead of 1.4oz/sqyrd. Even 3.2oz/sqyrd would be no problem for me if I would be sure to get 1st class quality.
I personally think that silpoly for tarp purposes will have no long future. It will survive silnylon but I think (based on my experience I got as hobby artist with different acrylic mediums) the future in the long run will be ripstop polyester with a thin durable acrylic coating. It's imo easier to manufacture, more user- and eco-friendly. I also think we will see tarps with very nice acrylic paintings in the future.
Bookmarks